Navigated to 30 Gifts that Gamers Will Love

AI vs. Recruiters: Who Does It Better?

By Carmen DeMint, CDR, Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist at Schell Games

February 6, 2025 · insights

  • Efficiency and Speed: AI can screen hundreds of resumes in the time it would take me to finish my coffee. The power of data processing means it can pull out keywords, analyze experience, and check skills faster than a human ever could. For high-volume hiring, this is a game-changer—it’s hard to argue with the efficiency when you’re dealing with thousands of applications.
  • Reducing Bias (in Theory): AI is often marketed as being “unbiased,” which is true to an extent. It doesn’t have conscious bias and doesn’t “prefer” one person over another based on appearance, accent, or personality. This can be a plus in creating a fair playing field—assuming the algorithm itself is designed thoughtfully and doesn’t carry hidden biases from its training data (which, spoiler, they sometimes do).
  • Consistency: Unlike humans who might have an off day, AI doesn’t get tired or forget details. It applies the same criteria uniformly across every resume, ensuring no one slips through the cracks for subjective reasons. It can be great for keeping hiring practices standardized and consistent.

  • Understanding Soft Skills and Culture Add: AI might be able to spot a resume with impressive technical skills, but it won’t know if a candidate is a collaborative team player, has the adaptability we need, or will bring fresh ideas that push the team forward. In game development, where the environment can be intense and teamwork is essential, culture add is everything. As recruiters, we talk to people, we ask questions, we get to know them beyond their credentials. AI can’t replace those insights.
  • Seeing the Potential Beyond the Keywords: AI can screen out candidates who don’t perfectly match the keywords, but human recruiters have the experience to look beyond the paper. I’ve hired incredible candidates who didn’t check every technical box but showed immense passion, drive, and adaptability—qualities that are crucial in game dev but don’t always come across in a digital scan.
  • Building Relationships: Let’s face it: AI doesn’t do “relationships.” One of the most fulfilling parts of my role is connecting with candidates on a personal level, understanding their career journeys, and guiding them through the hiring process. The empathy, encouragement, and guidance we offer as human recruiters simply can’t be programmed. Building trust and loyalty with candidates is what creates a lasting impact and strengthens our studio culture over time.
  • Adapting to the Nuances of Each Role and Team: No two roles are the same, and what works for one team may not work for another. AI may rely on standardized criteria, but as a recruiter, I work closely with hiring managers to understand the unique needs of each position, which allows me to make tailored hiring recommendations. I adapt my approach for each team, ensuring I’m helping to build a cohesive, creative, and high-performing group—not just filling a checklist.

Previous ArticleBlog HomeNext Article

Let's work together.

Contact Us